This study makes some interesting
comparisons between Texas and New York, and calls into question the commonly
held idea that locking people up reduces crime.
Texas leads US in
incarceration growth
Despite lackluster record on crime, one in 5
new prisoners added nationally during the 1990s were added in
Texas.
One out of 20 adult Texans under criminal justice
control
Washington, DC: The Texas prison system grew faster than
any other prison system in the country during the 1990s, adding nearly one
out of every 5 prisoners to the nation's prison boom. In a new study to
be released by the Washington, DC-based Justice Policy Institute on
August 29th, the criminal justice think tank found that one out of every
20 adults in Texas were either in prison, jail, on probation or on
parole. There are more people in prison in Texas than in any other state,
and Texas' incarceration rate is second only to Louisiana.
"Out of
every 20 adult Texans you meet, one is under criminal justice control,"
stated Vincent Schiraldi, the Institute's Director and report co-author. "The
sheer numbers of people in prison and jail in Texas are signs of system
fixated on punishment, and devoid of compassion."
Other significant
findings reported in the study include: Texas just earned the dubious
distinction of having the largest prison population in the country (163,190),
surpassing the prison population of California (163,067), which has 13
million more citizens than Texas. The Lone Star State has more than 700,000
of its citizens under criminal justice control.
The average annual
growth of Texas' prison population during the 1990s (11.8%) was not only the
highest growth in the nation, but was almost twice the average annual growth
of the other US states (6.1%) during the 1990s.
If Texas were a
country, it would have the highest incarceration rate in the world, easily
surpassing the United States and Russia, the next two finishers, and seven
times that of the next biggest prison system in China.
Blacks in Texas
are incarcerated at seven times the rate of whites, and nearly one in three
young African American men in Texas is under some form of criminal justice
control. The incarceration rate for Blacks in Texas is 63% higher than the
national incarceration rate for blacks. Despite adding more than 100,000
prisoners this decade, Texas' crime rate has declined much more slowly than
other large states. From 1995 to 1998, Texas' crime rate fell (-5.1%) at half
the national average (-10%), and the least of any of the nation's five
largest states [California (-23%), Florida (-5.9%), Illinois (-9.0%), or New
York (-21.1%)]. There are 89,400 people being incarcerated in Texas for
non-violent crimes. Standing alone amongst the states, Texas'
non-violent prison population represents the second largest incarcerated
population in the country (after California), and is larger than the entire
prisoner population (violent, and nonviolent) of the United Kingdom - a
country of 60 million people, or New York, the nation's third largest
state.
The Institute drew a specific comparison between Texas and New
York, the state closest in size to Texas. During the 1990s, Texas added
more prisoners to its prison system (+98,081) than New York's entire
prison population (73,233) by some 24,848 prisoners. This means that the
number of prisoners that Texas added during the 1990s was 34% higher than
New York's entire prison population. While Texas had the fastest
growing prison system in the country during the 1990s, New York had the
third slowest growing prison population in the US. Over all, during the
1990s, Texas added five times as many prisoners as New York did
(18,001).
Yet since 1995, the study found that New York's decline in
crime was four times greater than Texas' decline in crime. Texas'
current incarceration rate (1,035 per 100,000) is 80% higher than New
York's (574 per 100,000), yet Texas' crime rate (5,111 per 100,000) is
30% higher than New York's (3,588 per 100,000). In 1998, Texas' murder
rate was 25% higher than New York State's rate.
"If locking more
people up really reduced crime, Texas should have the lowest crime rate in
the country," says Jason Ziedenberg, Senior Researcher at the Institute and
report co-author. "The cost of having 1 in 3 young black men under criminal
justice control is a steep price to pay for the states' lackluster crime
declines."
Texas Tough: An Analysis of Incarceration and Crime Trends in
the Lone Star State is available for review by the media at www.cjcj.org/texas. The Justice Policy
Institute is a research and public policy organization in Washington, DC. JPI
is a project of the Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice. This study was
funded by a grant from the Center on Crime, Communities and
Culture.
Hope you are enjoying your Tidbits. If
you're not a member of ReconsiDer and would like to join please fill out our membership form.And be sure to visit our website.